This is the best way to reheat leftover pizza in the toaster oven. For hot & gooey pizza for lunch, dinner, snacks, or breakfast warm up a slice or more in the toaster oven. It only takes minutes & is so easy to do. Whole pizza instructions too. Times & temperatures for thin, regular, and deep-dish Chicago-style pizza.
Preheat the toaster oven for a few minutes at the temperature needed. Set the time and temperature according to the table above. It depends on the type of pizza and the thickness of the crust for the temperature. For thin crust - 375° for 2-3 minutes - for medium crust - 350° for 5 minutes & for deep dish - 350° for 8-10 minutes.For crispy pizza set it to 400°.
Once preheated, it is time to add the slices of pizza. Make sure to only add enough to the rack or pan as can fit in a single layer. Do not stack pizza slices.
Once the timer beeps, the pizza is ready. Remove carefully with tongs to a plate.
Enjoy!
Notes
SEE WHOLE PIZZA section above for times/temperatures when reheating a whole leftover pizza. This recipe is written for reheating 1-6 slices that are separated and placed in the toaster oven.