• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

The Short Order Cook

menu icon
go to homepage
  • Recipes
  • Food & Fun
  • Travel & Dining
  • Meet Angela
  • Work with Me
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
    • Twitter
    • YouTube
  • subscribe
    search icon
    Homepage link
    • Recipes
    • Food & Fun
    • Travel & Dining
    • Meet Angela
    • Work with Me
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
    • Twitter
    • YouTube
  • ×

    Home » Desserts

    Published: Oct 14, 2022 · Modified: Feb 13, 2023 by Angela · This post may contain affiliate links · 3 Comments

    Toaster Oven Peanut Butter Cookies

    Jump to Recipe

    No oven, no problem - you can still have fresh-baked peanut butter cookies thanks to the toaster oven. Baking cookies in a small appliance like a toaster oven is fun, easy, & quick. In less than 20 minutes you can have soft peanut butter cookies that are warm & yummy right out of the toaster oven. So if you ever wondered if you can bake cookies in a toaster oven; yes you can and they are delicious!

    This recipe makes a small batch of cookies, just 12 of them. Sometimes you only need a few cookies or you do not want leftovers, that is what makes this recipe so great. Since a toaster oven can only cook a few at a time, there is no need to spend hours rotating pan after pan in and out all day. A dozen cookies never tasted better. Mix, bake, & eat.

    Plate of fresh baked cookies.

    This cookie recipe is great for those that do not own a full-sized oven and only have access to a toaster oven. Ideal for college students in dorms, workplace lunch rooms, RVs, tiny houses, and more. Toaster ovens are inexpensive and you can find great ones for under $100.

    This was inspired by my recipe for small-batch peanut butter cookies on this site. Both are great when you only want a few cookies and 4-5 dozen. At my house kids and their friends seem to be hungry all the time. Knowing I can whip these up in no time makes me in the running for mom of the year - ok maybe I am the only one voting!

    Jump to:
    • Ingredients
    • Instructions
    • How to Make the Cookie Dough
    • Roll the Doug Balls
    • Can You Bake Cookies in the Toaster Oven?
    • Cool the Cookies
    • Substitutions & Variations
    • Equipment
    • Storage
    • FAQ
    • Toaster Oven Peanut Butter Cookies

    Ingredients

    To make a toaster oven peanut butter cookies you need all the same classic ingredients used in other recipes. It is just in a smaller amount. Baking is a science, so precise amounts as important. So please make the recipe as written without any changes.

    This recipe uses both baking powder and baking soda for a tender inside and crispy bottom. I like the puff that the baking powder does but also the soft texture that the baking soda adds. Together they make peanut butter cookies that are incredible.

    Ingredients for making peanut butter cookies in the toaster oven.
    • Creamy Peanut Butter
    • Salted Butter, softened
    • Egg Yolk, room temperature
    • Granulated Sugar
    • Brown Sugar
    • Vanilla Extra
    • All-Purpose Flour
    • Baking Powder
    • Baking Soda

    See the recipe card for quantities.

    Instructions

    Begin by bringing the butter and one egg yolk to room temperature. Room temperature ingredients are important when baking. The soft butter will cream with the sugar easier. In addition, a cold egg is harder to blend with ingredients.

    Gather a small mixing bowl and your hand mixer. The dough for this cookie recipe is a small amount so a small bowl and even a whisk can work. If you do not have a hand mixer, use a whisk. The small amount of cookie dough, hand whisked if you have a sturdy whisk.

    How to Make the Cookie Dough

    Once the ingredients are at room temperature, preheat the oven toaster oven to bake at 350°. This is for the regular bake setting, not convection or super convection (like an air fryer). If yours has a timer, set it for 8 minutes. Prep your toaster oven baking pan with foil and use some non-stick spray.

    Time for mixing up the dough. Making only a dozen cookies has all the same steps as it would when making a regular-sized recipe that makes dozens. It starts with creaming together some ingredients. Next, add the dry ingredients and mix.

    Hint: Save the white of this egg to use later. Add it as an extra egg white to one of my favorite recipes, leftover spaghetti with eggs.

    Creaming ingredients in a bowl.

    To a small mixing bowl add the creamy peanut butter, egg yolk, soft butter, & sugars. Using a hand mixer, mix on medium until smooth - about 1 minute.

    Adding flour to the wet ingredients.

    Next add the dry ingredients - flour, baking powder, & baking soda, to the creamed mixture. Mix again on medium speed for 1 minute.

    Crumbly dough in a bowl.

    The dough will seem crumbly and pebble-like. This is what it will look like and that is fine.

    Pressing the dough together with a rubber spatula.

    Use a rubber spatula to press the peanut butter cookie dough together. It will then be soft and look like this.

    This recipe doesn't require the peanut butter cookie dough to be refrigerated. You can bake as soon as the toaster oven is preheated. Time to bake!

    Tray of cookies in toaster oven with time and temp set.

    Roll the Doug Balls

    In a small bowl add the reserved 1 tablespoon of granulated sugar. Scoop out and roll 1 ½ tablespoons of dough in your hands to form a ball. Next, roll the ball in the granulated sugar to coat.

    Place the sugar-coated peanut butter dough ball on the toaster oven-sized baking pan. Repeat to make 6 dough balls. That is how many fit on my pan. You should have 6 balls of dough evenly spaced out. The other half of the dough can be baked in a second batch.

    Using a fork press lightly on each cookie ball. Press twice on each dough ball in a criss-cross pattern. The peanut butter cookie should not be too thin. Only press it ½ way down so it still is a bit thick.

    Can You Bake Cookies in the Toaster Oven?

    This yummy recipe will answer the question about just how can you bake cookies in a toaster oven. After one bite, you will know that the answer is #&*% yeah! Then next you will wonder why you haven't been doing this your whole life.

    Once the toaster oven is preheated to 350° it is time to bake. Bake the cookies for 8 minutes. Use an oven mitt to carefully remove the baking pan from the toaster oven. The cookies will still be light in color. Let them rest for 3-4 minutes on the pan before using a spatula to move them to a cooling rack.

    Toaster Oven Peanut Butter Cookies Cookies ready to come out of the toaster oven.

    Cool the Cookies

    Once the cookies have rested on the pan, use a spatula to move them to a cooling rack. I have a toaster oven pan that has a rack with it. This came in a toaster oven baking set and I love it. I use it for making bacon in the toaster oven too for perfectly crispy bacon every time.

    Cookies cooling on a rack.

    Substitutions & Variations

    This recipe is important to follow as written. The wet-to-dry ingredients ratios in this recipe are important and exact. Do not try and make alterations or substitutions to this toaster oven cookie recipe. They may end up soggy, dry, or with cookies that fall apart.

    Substitutions NOT recommended include the following:

    • Peanut Butter - do NOT use natural or crunchy peanut butter. Also, don't add your own chopped nuts. The cookies will turn out dry.
    • Flour - I have not tried to make this with other flour, such as gluten-free or almond flour. I do not recommend this substitution.

    If you want to add a few mix-ins to these cookies here is what I tried. Both of these variations were delish! (unlike the chopped nuts or crunch PB that didn't work)

    • Mini Chocolate Chips - add 1 Tablespoon of mini chocolate chips to the dough. Regular-sized chips are too big & cause the dough to fall apart.
    • Flaky Sea Salt - Sprinkle each one with flaky sea salt just as they come right out of the oven.
    Plated cookies fresh out of the toaster oven.

    Equipment

    The classic kitchen tools for making cookies are what is needed for this recipe. But you will need a toaster oven, obviously Here are some of my recommended products that make cookie baking in the toaster oven easy and yummy. I adore my toaster oven baking set! You can make so much in the toaster oven, from crispy bacon to fluffy baked potatoes.

    The Short Order Cook is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program.  As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.  If you click on a link and make a purchase, I may earn a small commission on the sale at no additional cost to you. This helps with the costs of running the blog. Thank you!  

    Storage

    These cookies are best fresh from the toaster oven. But if you do not eat them all on the same day, you can store them to enjoy later. Place cooled cookies in an air-tight container. Store in a cool & dry place for up to 5 days.

    The dough can be stored in the freezer and baked later. Wrap the dough in plastic wrap and store it in a ziplock bag for up to 2 months.

    Plate of cookies ready to eat.

    FAQ

    What if my toaster oven doesn't have a timer setting?

    That is ok, once you place your cookies in the toaster oven simply set a timer elsewhere. Whether that is on a good old-fashioned egg timer, a microwave oven, or a smartphone. 8 minutes is all these needs since the small baking quarters tend to cook these fast.

    Can you bake frozen cookie dough in the toaster oven?

    As mentioned above, this dough can be frozen to use later. So whether you want to bake it from frozen or have store-bought frozen cookie dough, go for it. Yes, you can bake cookies from frozen dough in a toaster oven.

    To bake frozen cookie dough, preheat the toaster oven to 350°. Add 2-3 minutes to the suggested cooking time when baking the cookies.

    Can I use parchment paper instead of foil in the toaster oven?

    Foil is the best option when baking in your toaster oven. It lines the baking pan well and is safe. Parchment paper has an increased fire hazard when used in a small area such as a toaster oven. I do not recommend using parchment paper when baking cookies in the toaster oven.

    Plated cookies ready to eat.

    Toaster Oven Peanut Butter Cookies

    Angela
    The best toaster oven peanut butter cookies are an easy & delicious recipe. This small batch recipe makes a dozen cookies that bake up perfectly in your toaster oven. Great for college students in dorms, RVs, small kitchens, and more.
    5 from 2 votes
    Print Recipe Pin Recipe
    Prep Time 10 mins
    Cook Time 8 mins
    Total Time 18 mins
    Course Dessert
    Cuisine American
    Servings 12

    Equipment

    • toaster oven
    • toaster oven baking pan

    Ingredients
      

    • ½ cup all-purpose flour
    • ¼ teaspoon baking soda
    • ¼ teaspoon baking powder
    • ⅓ cup creamy peanut butter not natural or crunchy
    • 3 tablespoons salted butter softened
    • 1 tablespoon brown sugar packed
    • 3 tablespoons - divided granulated sugar 1 tablespoon reserved for rolling the dough balls
    • 1 egg yolk room temperature
    • ¼ teaspoon vanilla extract

    Instructions
     

    • Bring the egg yolk and butter come to room temperature. Preheat the toaster oven to 350°. Line your baking pan with foil and coat with cooking spray.
    • In a small mixing bowl add the peanut butter, egg yolk, soft butter, brown sugar, and 2 tablespoons of the granulated sugars. Using a hand mixer, mix on medium until creamy and smooth. Mix for 1 minute.
    • Add the dry ingredients - flour, baking powder, & baking soda, to the creamed mixture. Mix again on medium speed for 1 minute.
    • The dough will look crumbly, loose, and pebble-like. This is ok and how it should look. Use a rubber spatula to press the peanut butter cookie dough together.
    • In a small bowl add the reserved 1 tablespoon of granulated sugar. Scoop out and roll 1 ½ tablespoons of cookie dough in your hands. Roll the dough ball in the granulated sugar to coat.
      Drop the sugar-coated peanut butter balls on the baking pan. Repeat with the rest of the dough. You should have 12 balls of dough evenly spaced on your cookie sheet.
    • Use a fork to press lightly on each dough ball. Press twice on each dough ball in a criss-cross pattern. Press each dough ball only ½ way down so it still is a bit thick.
    • Bake in the preheated toaster oven for 8 minutes. They will still be light in color and that is fine, this is not a dark brown peanut butter cookie. Using an oven mitt, carefully remove the baking sheet from the oven.
    • Let the cookies rest (which continues to cook them) on the hot baking sheet. Give them 2 more minutes on the baking sheet. Now you can use a spatula to move them to a cooling rack to finish cooling.
      Let cool for 10 minutes before eating. Or let cool for 20-30 minutes before storing in an air-tight container.

    Notes

    Nutrition Facts
    Servings: 12
    Amount per serving  
    Calories 109
    % Daily Value*
    Total Fat 6.9g 9%
    Saturated Fat 2.7g 14%
    Cholesterol 25mg 8%
    Sodium 82mg 4%
    Total Carbohydrate 10.2g 4%
    Dietary Fiber 0.6g 2%
    Total Sugars 5.4g  
    Protein 2.6g  
    Vitamin D 4mcg 18%
    Calcium 9mg 1%
    Iron 1mg 5%
    Potassium 66mg 1%
    *The % Daily Value (DV) tells you how much a nutrient in a food serving contributes to a daily diet. 2,000 calorie a day is used for general nutrition advice.
    Keyword baked, baked goods, dessert, nutty, sweet, toaster oven
    « How Much Pasta Per Person? (free printable)
    Steamed Frozen Vegetables »

    Reader Interactions

    Comments

      Leave a Reply Cancel reply

      Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

      Recipe Rating




    1. Elaine Ann says

      October 14, 2022 at 1:47 pm

      5 stars
      10 perfect cookies. I think I made them too big but they sure were good and cooked in the same amount of time. I did press them down a bit thinner so they would be done. I like a big cookie so I always scoop bigger than recipes say but 12 is a good number if you like regular ones.

      Reply
      • Angela says

        October 14, 2022 at 1:58 pm

        Nothing wrong with a big cookie.

        Reply
    2. Mia says

      November 01, 2022 at 5:16 pm

      5 stars
      So good.

      Reply

    Primary Sidebar

    Angela the short order cook on a step stool reaching into the top kitchen cupboard.

    Hi, I'm Angela I’m Angela, a petite mom that loves to cook, eat, drink, & explore all things food. I have been cooking since I could pull up a stool to finally reach the counter. I still rely on my trusty stool every day. I am a former personal chef turned blogger that hopes you find something new & tasty to love while you are here.

    More about me →

    This site has links to products/services that may make us a commission. #ad

    Popular

    • Pasta al Forno (baked pasta) featured in a casserole dish ready to eat
      Rigatoni al Forno (Baked Pasta)
    • A set of black pots and pans.
      Best Pots & Pans for Gas Stove
    • Cast Iron Chicken Breast cooked and Sliced in the pan.
      Cast Iron Chicken Breast
    • Water in a pitcher and glass to show ounces to gallon conversion.
      How Many Ounces in a Gallon (Free Printable Charts)
    • Homemade Snickers Bars featured 5 stack
      Homemade Snickers Bars
    • Overhead of cast iron skillet with creamy coconut chicken thighs ready to top with cilantro, green onion, and hot sauce.
      Creamy Coconut Chicken 
    • A bun topped with 3-ingredient sloppy joe meat and cheese.
      3-Ingredient Sloppy Joes (Gluten-Free)
    • Best Ever Mango Ice Cream featured two bowls close mango bottom corner
      Best Ever Mango Ice Cream (with Ice Cream Maker)

    The Short Order Cook LLC is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com

    #ad The Short Order Cook LLC is an affiliate of ButcherBox. I have been a customer for years and cannot recommend it enough. Great prices & even better meat! Sign up today.

    Footer

    ↑ back to top

    About

    • Privacy Policy
    • Cookie Policy
    • Terms of Service
    • Disclosure Policy

    Newsletter

    • Sign Up! for emails and updates

    Contact

    • Contact
    • Work With Me
    • Meet Angela
    • Meet the Family

    Copyright © 2023 The Short Order Cook LLC All recipes, photos, and articles on this site are the property of The Short Order Cook LLC. You are welcome to share a photo ONLY with an accompanied do-follow link back to this site. Publishing any items as if they were your own is prohibited.

    This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish.AcceptReject Read Privacy Policy
    Privacy & Cookies Policy

    Privacy Overview

    This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience.
    Necessary
    Always Enabled
    Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
    Non-necessary
    Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.
    SAVE & ACCEPT